Credit Unions vs Banks: Where Should You Keep Your Money?

a sign communicating which should they use, a bank or a credit union

When it comes to choosing a financial institution for your checking, savings, and financial needs, you have two primary options: a credit union vs a bank. Although banks and credit unions offer similar services and products, they are actually two different types of financial institutions. Let's take a closer look at the similarities and differences between banks and credit unions.

What Is a Credit Union?

A credit union is a not-for-profit financial institution or cooperative that is owned by the people who utilize its financial services. The cooperative, not-for-profit structure of credit unions means they exist to help members with a shared bond achieve greater financial well-being. This doesn't mean credit unions are unprofitable. Instead, the profits generated by the credit union are used to further serve the member-owners in the form of more attractive rates and dividends.

What Is a Bank?

A bank is a for-profit financial institution licensed to accept savings and checking deposits. In addition to an array of lending products, banks can offer other financial services, such as:

  • Safe deposit boxes
  • Currency exchange
  • Individual retirement accounts
  • And more
  • Different Types of Banks

    While retail banks that offer general banking services are the most prevalent, there are several other types of banks:

  • Corporate and commercial banks tailor their services to business clients, ranging from large corporate entities to small business owners.
  • Investment banks offer corporate clients complex financial transactions and services.
  • Central banks are independent institutions with governmental authority to oversee the monetary policy and money supply of a nation.
  • Differences Between Credit Unions and Banks

    The primary difference between banks and credit unions is the ownership structure:

  • Banks are owned by shareholders or investors, and
  • Credit union cooperatives are owned by owner-members.
  • This distinction underscores many of the variations between banks and credit unions.

    Bank vs Credit Union's Primary Focus

    Banks are guided by maximizing shareholder value. This doesn't mean banks overlook the needs of their customers. Instead, customer needs are aligned with products that increase shareholder value. In contrast, credit unions are focused on delivering a best-in-class member experience.

    Credit Unions Typically Have Higher Deposit Rates Compared to Banks

    When for-profit banks are profitable, their shareholders benefit in the form of year-end dividends and increased stock value. When not-for-profit credit unions are profitable, the profits are passed onto the member-owners in the form of dividends and:

  • Lower loan rates
  • Lower mortgage rates
  • Higher yields on deposit checking and savings accounts
  • Higher yields on CDs and other investment vehicles
  • Lower and fewer service fees
  • Banks Typically Have More Advanced Technology & Are More Accessible

    In today's age of technology and mobile banking, banks have a clear edge over credit unions. While most banks offer innovations like mobile check deposit, peer-to-peer payment solutions, and biometric technology, fewer credit unions have the infrastructure to adopt these solutions. Banks are also larger, offer more branches, and have a larger ATM network, which makes these institutions more accessible.

    Bank vs Credit Union's Qualifications to Join or Enroll

    For the most part, anyone can join a bank as long as basic financial and citizenship criteria are met. However, to join a credit union, you must share a common bond and be within the institution's Field of Membership (FOM) based on the Federal Credit Union Act of 1934. Examples of FOM requirements include:

  • An employee of a specific employer
  • An employee within a specific field
  • A member of an affiliation or association, such as a civic organization or worker's union
  • A resident of a community, neighborhood, county, city, or other well-defined geographic boundaries.
  • A family member of someone who meets the criteria
  • Credit Union Members vs Bank Customers

    Banks have customers. Credit unions have members who double as owners.

    How Are They Similar?

    Although credit unions and banks have several differences, they share similarities.

    Banks and Credit Unions Offer Similar Products

    Banks and credit unions offer a very similar lineup of products and services, such as:

  • Checking accounts
  • Savings accounts
  • Online banking
  • Direct deposit
  • Certificate of Deposits (CDs)
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • Money transfers
  • Mortgages
  • Home equity loans and lines of credit
  • Credit Unions and Banks Offer Deposit Safety

    Both banks and credit unions offer depositors a level of safety in the form of insurance on the money deposited.

  • For banks, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) automatically offers standard insurance of $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each account ownership category.
  • The National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) government agency manages and operates the National Credit Union Share Insurance Fund (NCUSIF), which acts similarly to the FDIC. The NCUSIF provides all members of federally insured credit unions with up to $250,000 of coverage for single accounts.
  • FAQs About Banks vs Credit Unions

    Is a Credit Union Safer Than a Bank?

    Both credit unions and banks are federally insured, so they’re considered equally safe. However, deposits at credit unions are insured by the NCUSIF, while deposits at banks are insured by the FDIC.

    Are There Downsides to Using a Credit Union?

    One perceived downside of credit unions is they tend to have fewer branches than traditional banks. To overcome this problem, simply find a credit union that is part of a shared branch network to avoid this issue.

    Sources

    1. 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households
    2. How is a credit union different than a bank? │MyCreditUnion.gov
    3. Find, Join or Start a Credit Union │MyCreditUnion.gov
    4. What's a Credit Union? │Elements Financial
    5. What Are Common Types of Banks │Credit Karma
    6. How Banking Works, Types of Banks, and How To Choose the Best Bank For You
    7. What is a credit union?
    8. Credit Unions: Nonprofit or Not-for-Profit, What's the Difference?
    9. In the Know: Credit Union Statistics - Extensia Financial
    10. Credit Union Field of Membership │CUCollaborate
    11. FDIC: Deposit Insurance
    12. Are Credit Unions FDIC Insured by the Government?
    13. Credit unions, shares, and dividends: The root of the industry's distinctive terminology - CUInsight
    14. COMPS-264.pdf
    15. Frequently Asked Questions on Member Capital and Dividend Payouts │NCUA
    16. Choose a Field of Membership │NCUA
    17. Historical Timeline │NCUA
    18. Historical documents │USAGov

    Recent Posts

    Pros & Cons of Having a Cosigner on Your Loan

    When applying for a loan or line of credit, you may be told that it would be beneficial to have a co-signer to help you qualify. Having a co-signer on your loan can have both benefits and drawbacks and both should be carefully considered before having them sign on the dotted line.

    What is a co-signer, and what are the benefits and drawbacks of having one on your loan?

    Read More >
    How Do Personal Loans Affect Credit Score?

    A hard credit inquiry, increase in personal debt, and your payment records can all have an impact on your credit score, and there’s a potential it could be negative or positive over time. Still, a personal loan is often needed and very beneficial. So, how does it potentially affect your credit score? Read on and find out.

    Read More >
    Soft vs Hard Credit Check

    Lenders, employers, and other entities rely on your credit score to help determine your creditworthiness and responsibility. Because the information in your credit file is confidential, only legally permitted entities can access it through a credit inquiry. Let's answer the question "What is a credit inquiry" and explore the difference between a soft inquiry and a hard inquiry.

    Read More >

    Apply Quickly & Securely

    Apply Quickly
    & Securely

    Fast, short and
    secure application
    Instant approval
    decision
    Choose how much
    cash you need
    Money in your account
    as early as tomorrow*